Cast | TEETH, A Coming-of-Rage Musical Comedy

Alyse Alan Louis

Dawn O’Keefe

Lucille Lortel & Outer Critics Circle Award Nominations for Teeth (Dawn/Playwrights Horizons/Original Cast Recording). Since 2011, she’s been part of Teeth’s development. Broadway: Amélie (OCR), Disaster!, Mamma Mia! Off-Broadway: Drama Desk Award Nomination for Soft Power (Hillary/The Public/Grammy-nominated OCR); White Girl In Danger (Second Stage/OCR); A New Brain (Encores Off Center/OCR); The Civilians’ Pretty Filthy (Abrons/OCR). @alyselouis

Andy Karl

Pastor Bill O’Keefe

Andy Karl has an Olivier Award, 3 Tony nominations and is thrilled to join Teeth. Broadway highlights: Rocky, Groundhog Day, Into The Woods, On The Twentieth Century, Legally Blonde. On screen: “Law & Order SVU,” Joyful Noise, And So It Goes and Jersey Boys opposite Nick Jonas. Gird your loins. @andy_karl

Will Connolly

Brad O’Keefe

Broadway: Once (OBC). Off-Broadway & Regional: Fly By Night (co-writer), Teeth (Playwrights Horizons), Clueless (New Group), This Ain’t No Disco (Atlantic), After The Blast (LCT3), Once (NYTW, A.R.T.), Spacebar (Wild Project), Be More Chill (Two River). Film/TV: “The Gilded Age,” “Chicago Med,” “Deadbeat,” “Person of Interest.” MFA: Yale School of Drama.

Jason Gotay

Tobey

Broadway/NYC: Teeth (Playwrights Horizons), Bring It On: The Musical, Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark, Evita (NYCC/Encores!), A Little Night Music in Concert (Lincoln Center), Renascence (Transport Group). TV/Film: “Gossip Girl” (HBO Max), Spoiler Alert (Focus Features), “Peter Pan Live!” (NBC). His solo show Where You’ll Find Me is available on Audible. Follow @jasongotay.

Jared Loftin

Ryan

Off-Broadway/New York: Teeth (Playwrights Horizons), The Panic of ’29 (59E59), Gigantic (Vineyard Theatre), Saturday Night (York Theatre). Regional: AD16 (Olney Theatre), Nikola Tesla Drops the Beat (ATF), Peter Pan, All Shook Up, Fame, Joseph…Dreamcoat (Artpark). Film/TV: tick, tick…BOOM! (Netflix), “Little America” (Apple), “Red Oaks” (Amazon).

Julia Bain

Understudy Becky, Trisha, Keke, Fiona

National Tour: Waitress. Select NYC/Regional: Teeth (Playwrights Horizons), How To Build A Bomb, Into The Woods, The Marvelous Wonderettes, Sylvia, All Shook Up. BFA: Ithaca College. Gratitude to the Teeth team, and Henderson Hogan. Endless love to my family, LKC, my doggos, and Noah. @juliabain or juliabain.com

Courtney Bassett

Promise Keeper Girl Becky

Broadway: The Great Comet. Off-Broadway/NYC selects: Teeth, Titanique, Bedbugs!!! Regional faves: The Great Comet, Pop! (Who Shot Andy Warhol?). Concerts: Lincoln Center, Joe’s Pub, LPR, Broadway Sings. Film/TV: “BROS,” “Manifest,” “The Today Show,” “Good Morning America,” “The Tony Awards.” Singer/Songwriter for band Starbird & the Phoenix. @thecourtneybassett

Sean Doherty

Understudy Tobey, Brad, Ryan

Off-Broadway: Teeth (Playwrights Horizons). National Tour: Jagged Little Pill. Regional: Eighty-Sixed (Diversionary Theatre). Special thanks to his family, friends, and most importantly, his boyfriend Ashton for always cooking dinner, walking Chuck, and being the best. Love you. Instagram: @SeanDDoherty. Twitter: @SeanDoherty

Jenna Rose Husli

Promise Keeper Girl Trisha

Jenna Rose Husli is so excited to be a part of telling this insanely brilliant story on stage once again! Her recent credits include Sister Mary Patrick in the international tour of Sister Act and Princess Pamela in Head Over Heels at Madison Theatre.

Kyra Kennedy

Standby Dawn, Understudy Rachael, Stephanie

Recently: Carole King, Beautiful (Paper Mill Playhouse, MSMT); Kat Arujo in the World Premiere of Mystic Pizza the Musical (Ogunquit Playhouse, La Mirada Theatre, West Coast Tour); Monica Lewinsky in the World Premiere play When Monica Met Hillary (Miami New Drama). First National Tour: Waitress (Jenna/Dawn cover) @kyramkennedy

Micaela Lamas

Promise Keeper Girl Rachael

Micaela Lamas is a Texas State Musical Theatre grad, south Texas native, and is so excited to be making her Off-Broadway debut in Teeth! Recent credits: Alana Beck in Dear Evan Hansen (tour). Much love to the entire Teeth team, CGF, and her friends & family! @micaelajlamas

Madison McBride

Promise Keeper Girl Keke

TV/Film: “Full Circle” (HBO), No Hard Feelings (Columbia Pictures). International: Clueless The Musical (UK Premiere). New York: Teeth (Playwrights Horizons), The Pirates of Penzance (Roundabout Pre-Broadway). Regional: Next to Normal (Barrington Stage Company), Bhangin’ It (La Jolla Playhouse), Beautiful (North Carolina Theatre), Beauty and the Beast (Ann Arbor in Concert). BFA University of Michigan ’21 @madison_mcb

Sydney Parra

Promise Keeper Girl Fiona, Understudy Dawn

Sydney Parra is absolutely geeked to be joining this incredible monster of a show. Past credits: Six Nat’l tour, Hadestown Nat’l tour, We Are The Tigers. Huge thanks to Lohne/Graham mgmt, AAG, and the entire company of Teeth. All the love to my family. @sydneyparra

Wren Rivera

Promise Keeper Girl Stephanie

Wren Rivera feels incredibly lucky to be back in this dental dream ballet. They’ve been lucky to be in Jagged Little Pill on Broadway, play Jules in Between The Lines Off-Broadway, and make their television debut on Apple TV’s “We Crashed” amongst other wonderful projects. They are represented by Nicolosi & Co. and Emery Entertainment. Follow along: @w.t.rivera

James D. Sasser

Understudy Pastor/Godfather, Truthseeker/Dr. Godfrey

Broadway/Tours: Riverdance, Jesus Christ Superstar (Pilate). Off-Broadway: Teeth, Suburb, Forbidden Broadway, Showtune. Regional: South Pacific (Emile/TUTS), Sweeney Todd (Sweeney/FCMT), Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (Lawrence/Engeman), Curious Incident... (Ed/Village Theatre), A Little Night Music (Fredrik), and more. TV: “Succession,” “Madam Secretary.” MSM & NYU-Tisch GMTWP graduate. Writer/Producer. @jamesdsasser